UFC Books Frankie Edgar vs. Ben Henderson Title Rematch

[Bella79]

Originally Posted by JavierDLC

Awee come on Meli I wasn't attacking you I was just giving you an example...

No worries! Just have to spout off every now and then.. Come on this place would be boring if I agreed with you MEN..

[County Mike]

Originally Posted by Bella79

Why whenever I mention anything on here you boys feel the need to throw Bj or Chael in my face?

Someone threw a BJ in your face? Wowza!

[JavierDLC]

[Bella79]

Originally Posted by County Mike

Someone threw a BJ in your face? Wowza!

Errr, NO.

[rearnakedchoke]

Originally Posted by Bella79

Chael did not get an automatic rematch. He had to fight Stann and Bisping..

he got an automatic rematch and was suspended ..

[JavierDLC]

Originally Posted by rearnakedchoke

he got an automatic rematch and was suspended ..

Yeah thats true

Chael would have defended his belt like 3 or 4 times by now.

[kevint13]

I have a question....what was the state of the LW and MW divisions when BJ and Chael would have gotten an immediate rematch? Were there any other true contenders at that time?

I am asking because I don't remember....I think Vitor was the only one at MW at that time. Where I am going with this is if there were no true contenders deserving of a shot at the title then a rematch was the right thing to do.

[rockdawg21]

I thought it was pretty obvious that Henderson won, but the fight was exciting so I'm not complaining about watching it again!

[J.B.]

Originally Posted by rockdawg21

I thought it was pretty obvious that Henderson won

I thought it was pretty obvious that Henderson was going to win, but I guess people seem to like Edgar.(too bad they don't actually buy PPV's)...

I also thought the rematches that Edgar had to endure were obvious. Call me crazy, but I remember that he barely beat BJ the first time and he fought to a draw in the 2nd fight with Gray. As if those are the worst rematches we have seen in UFC history.

[Max]

I think that if there is a clear cut #1 contender then you dont do the rematch, but in this case no one really stands out in the LW division so I'm fine with it.