Originally Posted by adamt
okay this isn't a controversy this time, as it all worked out, BUT if miss foxy or ufcfan2 had won the tie breaker, would they have won, even though they didn't get the actual fight correct? that wouldn't have worked so well if they had bj winning by ud, but it was actually edgar, see what i am saying?
Well...if They had said BJ by U Dec...and LC87 had said Frankie by Split Dec....which guess is closer?
Frankie...because even though he said split decision...he at least got the prediction correct, not just the tie break.
Now if LC87 had not existed
and Miss Foxy and UFCfan2 both said BJ Penn by Decision...then I would defer to the person who made the prediction first.
That sort of dead heat is VERY unlikely...because they have to be equal on points, equal on the person, and equal on the method...which is nigh on impossible unless its a decision.
IF one had said U-Dec and one said Split Dec...but both for BJ....then U Dec would win, being closer then split dec, besides them both being wrong about the person
Does that help clarify matters