Your MMA Pound-for-Pound Rankings

Originally Posted by atomdanger

I think most of the problem with peoples p4p list is they use too much opinion,
or speculation.

Fedor is proven.

That's pure speculation!!

OK, brought back this thread as my rankings have changed over this weekend and made my decision tougher ... I think I am gonna go with ..

1. Anderson Silva
2. GSP
3. Fedor
4. BJ
5. Machida

I could think of switching Fedor and BJ as I don't know how long I can keep Fedor top three for not fighting the best at HW ... I think he is the best and would beat people, but my opinion is one thing .. i need results

Originally Posted by rearnakedchoke

OK, brought back this thread as my rankings have changed over this weekend and made my decision tougher ... I think I am gonna go with ..

1. Anderson Silva
2. GSP
3. Fedor
4. BJ
5. Machida

I could think of switching Fedor and BJ as I don't know how long I can keep Fedor top three for not fighting the best at HW ... I think he is the best and would beat people, but my opinion is one thing .. i need results

Agree with this list 100%. I use to have GSP at 1 but the Anderson I saw saturday night is p4p the best fighter ever in mma.

1.Matt Hughes - I don't give a 2 cents what anyone sias, Matt is still my top p4p fighter
2. Fedor
3.Anderson Silva
4.GSP
5.BJ Penn