Your MMA Pound-for-Pound Rankings

1. Fedor
2. Anderson
3. GSP
then the rest

Originally Posted by Hughes_GOAT

Fedor
Machida
Silva
Penn
GSP

This

Fedor
A. Silva
Machida
GSP
Penn

Hmmm you know what I think is weird... Alot of people put Penn and GSP in P4P rankings... But Hughes has wins over both of them....

Originally Posted by sender

Hmmm you know what I think is weird... Alot of people put Penn and GSP in P4P rankings... But Hughes has wins over both of them....

i don't think that's weird at all. P4P has nothing to do with wins 3-4 years ago, it is based on recent activity and that is why most people don't put hughes up with the others right now.

hughes was once #1 P4P back in his prime and if he beats thiago (if he fights thiago next) that might put him back in some of the top 10 P4P rankings

anyways my rankings are

fedor
gsp
machida
anderson
penn

Fedor
Silva
Machida
Penn
GSP

alright, i thought about this yesterday .. and I am changing my rankings .. (can I do that?)

1. GSP
2. Penn
3. Anderson
4. Fedor
5. Machida

I am doing this based on a couple of things ... One, GSP has fought the toughest relative competititon .. I think since he has been in the UFC, he has fought all Top-Tens at the time in his weight class except for Hieron and Miller (they may have been top ten back then, but i wasn't too familiar with world rankings then) he has dominated every fighter he has fought and avenged all losses on his record
BJ, as much as I think he is a douche, the dude has never lost at his weight class ... he has also fought out of his weight class for which he gets points .. sure he has lost probably half of them, but it takes balls to fight bigger guys .. he should stay at 155 as I think he can beat some WW's, he can't beat GSP
Anderson has cleaned up his weight class and is fighting at LHW now .. he could probably go up in the rankings, but i think his last few fights have been against less relative competition
Fedor, one of my favourite fighters who has truly never lost .. but until he starts fighting the best HW's in the world, he can't move up ... I think he beats anyone in the UFC, but that is opinion .. Fedor, please make it a reality and come beat these guys ...
Machida ... chance to be the best when he starts fighting better .. sure he has never lost a round, but beating the likes of hoger, nakmura and some other bum .. when he beats guys like rampage, shogun, he will move to number 1

GSP
Fedor
Machida
A.Sliva
Penn

[Tyburn]

Let me think about it

IMO you cannot rank anybody above Fedor,
for several reasons.

For one, he has zero legitimate losses.
(google the story of his one loss, I won't explain it again)
He has faced everybody important in the HW division,
although seeing him fight Randy when he was on top would have been nice.
He also has beaten everybody in dominating and convincing fashion.

People rank GSP, but not only does he have losses,
but he isn't walking through guys, he is even being boring while winning.
*shrug*

AS, ehhhh.. He is good, but has had problems in his fights.
Lutter mounted him, Hendo held him down, and he hasn't been able to put guys away like he used to.

p4p means if everybody was the same weight who would be the best.
Do you guys honestly think the GSP and AS's we've been seeing would beat Fedor?