MHF Battle of the Bands 2009 (Round 1)

Originally Posted by JB Rattlesnake

Eric Clapton > Jimmy Page IMO

Don't get me wrong, I like some LZ, but I also find them to be one of the most over-rated bands ever. Along with The Beatles.

Eric Clapton is better than Page I agree but Robert Plant was in my opinion one of the best singers in any classic rock band and that coupled with Page's guitar was pretty great.

How can some of you not select METALLICA.. Are you serious???

[NateR]

Originally Posted by JB Rattlesnake

So, here is the first round...

Led Zepplin vs Cream

Pink Floyd vs Black Sabbath

Jimi Hendrix vs Soundgarden

Queen vs AC/DC

Metallica vs The Sex Pistols

Aerosmith vs Nirvana

KISS vs Van Halen

Guns n Roses vs The Who

Okay, there it is people! Now VOTE!

Led Zeppelin
Pink Floyd
Hendrix
AC/DC
Metallica
Aerosmith
Van Halen
The Who (as much as it pains me to vote against GNR, I'm just more likely to listen to The Who than their music)

[NateR]

Originally Posted by Llamafighter

Tommy, nuff said

Yep, one of the greatest albums ever.

Originally Posted by Josh

Eric Clapton is better than Page I agree but Robert Plant was in my opinion one of the best singers in any classic rock band and that coupled with Page's guitar was pretty great.

Plant is the reason i don't like LZ, his voice irritates me, I can tolerate the music if it was all instrumental

[J.B.]

Originally Posted by Josh

Led Zepplin

Pink Floyd

Jimi Hendrix

Queen

Metallica

Aerosmith

The Who

Hey Josh, you forget to pick for KISS vs Van Halen!

[J.B.]

Here are some early totals for the first round.

As of right now we have had 10 people vote.

Led Zeppelin is beating Cream 7 to 3

Pink Floyd and Black Sabbath are tied at 5 votes a piece

Jimi Hendrix is dominating Soundgarden 8 to 2

AC/DC is edging out Queen 6 to 4

Metallica is beating the Sex Pistols 7 to 3

Aerosmith is beating Nirvana 7 to 3

Van Halen is beating KISS 6 to 4 (thanks for your vote Josh!)

and GNR is edging out The Who 6 to 4

I am working on Photoshopping a Bracket too, just been a little busy, but I will post it soon.

Originally Posted by JB Rattlesnake

Hey Josh, you forget to pick for KISS vs Van Halen!

Sorry. That's a tough one for me. I pick KISS.

[J.B.]

Originally Posted by JB Rattlesnake

Here are some early totals for the first round.

As of right now we have had 10 people vote.

Led Zeppelin is beating Cream 7 to 3

Pink Floyd and Black Sabbath are tied at 5 votes a piece

Jimi Hendrix is dominating Soundgarden 8 to 2

AC/DC is edging out Queen 6 to 4
Metallica is beating the Sex Pistols 7 to 3

Aerosmith is beating Nirvana 7 to 3

Van Halen is beating KISS 6 to 4

and GNR is edging out The Who 6 to 4

I am working on Photoshopping a Bracket too, just been a little busy, but I will post it soon.

Come on people! All ACDC songs sound the same. Queen at least had some variety. Not that I don't like ACDC I just think Queen outclasses them. Wow I am taking this thing way too serious.