View Single Post
Old 12-30-2013, 06:02 PM
kevint13's Avatar
kevint13 kevint13 is offline
Student of the Sport
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Greeley, CO
Posts: 685

Originally Posted by Vizion View Post
I never said you did say that. The UFC says that. They make the claim that Anderson is the best MMA fighter in the history of the world. Their qualifications, their script. Am I false?

Forrest was scripted to lose that fight. I know the UFC was hoping for a better scrap, but Forrest lost his motivation long before that fight and they knew it, so they gave Anderson Forrest, very far from the best, so going up to LHW to fight 3 stooges near the bottom of the ladder proved very little.

I don't think all fighters are given cans. I agree with my boy Jon Jones in that he has had to take serious fights, and many others have had to as well. But you're buying into the HYPE the UFC is selling about Anderson Silva, maybe your love for MMA has clouded your vision here. The claims they make are WITHOUT merit about this guy. He hasn't beaten the best. He's beaten the guys and the cans they gave him TO beat.

First fight out they put him against Chris Leben...who is, was and always will be an "eh" fighter. AS wins, I'll give him that, but that moved him to the #1 MW spot? I don't think that was a gift so much as a be it.

Second fight he gets Rich Franklin for a title shot...Ok, same deal, but Rich was an awesome fighter and for some reason he was 1-dimensional in that fight and was clinched up by AS.

Third fight TUF season 4 winner Travis Lutter...a season of crappy fighters who were thrown out of the UFC, then brought back for a shot at redemption. This was Anderson's first "gift" from the UFC. Even still Lutter had a good showing overall, he just gassed, yet the UFC toted AS as "unstoppable" at this point bc of this fight. The script began with this fight.

Fourth fight Marquardt - OK, he proved himself legitimate again like with Franklin. The script gets its first real merit.

Fifth fight Franklin again, and again the same result. The script get richer. There is talk about deification now.

Sixth fight Hendo - OK, though Hendo wasn't the machine of invincibility the script wrote him out to be, but the script paints a different picture.

Seventh-Tenth fights - all of these guys were gifts for Anderson, and the 2 title shots in there were a joke to say the least. None of those fighters are with the UFC anymore. Per the script you'd think everyone of those fighters were top 3 in the world, once again cementing how indestructible AS was.

Eleventh fight Meia - I wouldn't say Meia was a total can, but AS clowned him the whole time and the fight was a farce. AS proved himself brilliant at playing mind games with his opponents. The script gets better because they can show the pyscological aspects of AS game.

Twelfth fight Chael 1 - AS gets dominated 4.5 rounds by Chael with his 1 dimensional strategy, and then Chael (much like Anderson with Weidmann ) fails himself and loses the himself. Of course, the psycological aspect gets blotted out of the script in this fight since Chael didn't succumb to any fear.

Thirteenth fight Vitor - I'll give him that one. Vitor however, had only beaten Franklin at this point in the UFC, and Franklin had been up and down against OK fighters for the most part since losing to AS. So, how legitimate was the victory?

Fourteenth fight Okami - an obligatory title shot much the same as Cote and Leites, and those guys were gifts, so Okami was also another gift.

Fifteenth fight Chael 2 - another 1 dimensional fight on Chael's end which cost him, not a gift, but once again like Anderson/Weidmann 1 - Chael lost that fight on account of himself

Sixteenth fight Bonner - a gift, plain and simple.

The UFC deems this guy "the greatest Mixed Martial Artist of all time", the "greatest martial artist of all time", and the "most dominant mma fighter of all time", yet, he wasn't dominant in every round of every fight, nor is their sufficient merit to define him undisputably the greatest MMA fighter of all time when his opponents by and large were questionable opponents.

That's the only issue I have. I do think for whatever it's worth that AS is the best MW the UFC championship has had, but I don't think AS is the best UFC MW and def not the best the world has to offer. According the script you'd think it would blasphemous to say such things, but I think Chris WM just proved again that AS has holes, can be exposed and can lose. I think Machida, Rashad, Souza and other company would prove the same theory.

Only problem is the UFC doesn't want that in the script so therefore the script revision must read that AS probably/most likely lost "to himself" much the same way BJ Penn lost the first Frankie fight "to himself"

I'd have to look into that, I didn't follow the UFC through most of Matt's reign.
I get what you are saying for the most part, I don't totally agree but when does that ever happen?

I don't understand your "script" theory. You make it seem like the UFC picked him and decided that they were going to make him successful. Now if you mean after they saw him wreck Leben and Franklin...I could see why they would want to, but I just don't think they would do this (I could be wrong though).

I went and looked back and Anderson was never a huge "betting" favorite until he fought James Irvin (There was no data for Leben, Franklin 1, or Lutter).

UFC 162: Anderson Silva -215 / Chris Weidman +165
UFC 153: Anderson Silva -1350 / Stephan Bonnar +850
UFC 148: Anderson Silva -235 / Chael Sonnen +175
UFC 134: Anderson Silva -425 / Yushin Okami +325
UFC 126: Anderson Silva -325 / Vitor Belfort +250
UFC 117: Anderson Silva -450 / Chael Sonnen +300
UFC 112: Anderson Silva -425 / Demian Maia +325
UFC 101: Anderson Silva -240 / Forrest Griffin +190
UFC 97: Anderson Silva -275 / Thales Leites +215
UFC 90: Anderson Silva -370 / Patrick Cote +300
UFC Fight Night 14: Anderson Silva -600 / James Irvin +400
UFC 82: Anderson Silva -140 / Dan Henderson +100
UFC 77: Anderson Silva -300 / Rich Franklin +220
UFC 73: Anderson Silva -190 / Nate Marquardt +155
Based on these and provided that casino sportsbooks offered comparable, it wouldn't seem that everyone thought he was fighting complete cans.

I'm not buying into the hype that you believe that the UFC is trying to promote on Anderson Silva. I am looking at what he has done and how he has done it. I am looking at it from a P4P view. Anderson in his prime with his skills could beat anyone in the world, that is what I believe. It is all subjective and you disagreeing is cool. I just want you to see where I am coming from and we can still disagree. I would be willing to bet that RNC would think the same about GSP too and you possibly about Jon Jones now or in the near future. But it isn't the UFC's hype machine that makes me feel this way, it is Anderson's style and skills that make me believe it.
Reply With Quote