Originally Posted by rearnakedchoke
1. Anderson Silva - sure he lost 4 rounds to chael before subbing him, sure it looks like he is avoiding sonnen, but until he loses he is the best there has ever been
2. Jon Jones - takes over gsp imo .. beating rampage, lyoto and shogun in a career is amazing .. doing it in a year??? wow ..
3. GSP - losing ground to edgar, but still number 3 .. out for a while, but will be back ... should add to his record of consecutive ww title defences when he rturns over diaz or condit
4. Frankie Edgar - looked out of it again in round 1, but came back and defended his title in great style and avenged his only loss ..
5. Jose Aldo - defended his title again ... looks to defend against undefeated mendes .. should be a good battle
Gilbert Melendez - If he ever gets to the UFC, we should see how he does against real LW's
Your analysis is out of whack.. Your going to question #1 when #3 is doing the same..